The short answer
Keep the TMS as the record of the load, and judge the tracking on one question: when a truck is going to miss its appointment, who finds out first, and from what? If the honest answer is a dispatcher who called, or the customer, then the tracking you have is a status field, whatever the TMS calls it, and a track and trace tool beside the TMS is the fix. If the answer is that the board raised the load from the truck's own position before anyone asked, keep what you have and spend the money elsewhere.
What tracking in a TMS usually is
Tracking inside a TMS tends to be one of three things, and a demo will not always say which. The first is a status field: Dispatched, In transit, Delivered, typed by a dispatcher after a check call or a driver's text. The TMS stores the status and the time it was typed. It does not know whether the status is still true or where the truck has been since, and nothing happens when the field goes untouched for a day.
The second is a visibility vendor connected to the TMS, so that positions from the vendor's network show on the load screen. Where that is working it is a real position source, and the freight visibility comparison sets out what each vendor publishes about its network. What the connection does with the position inside the TMS varies, which is what the questions below are for.
The third is the TMS vendor's own driver app or carrier portal, which gives you a position for the drivers who install it and nothing for the ones who do not. Drivers have said in public, for a decade, that they will not put one more tracking app on a personal phone, and the carrier's ELD is usually the better source where the carrier will share it.
One argument from the shipper side does not apply to you. Articles written for shippers warn that a TMS only sees the freight that runs through it. At a brokerage every load runs through the TMS, so coverage is not the gap. The gap is what the TMS does between dispatch and delivery, on its own, while nobody has the load open.
Six questions for your TMS vendor
Ask these of the TMS vendor, of its visibility integration, and of any tool you would put beside it. Write the answers down.
- Where does a load's position come from, and does the screen say how old it is? A pin with no age is a status field with a map behind it.
- What happens, on its own, when a position stops arriving? Who is told, after how many minutes, and what does the system do before it tells a person? If the answer is that the load keeps its last status until someone notices, that is the moment the customer finds out first.
- Is the ETA compared with the appointment on every new position, or only when someone opens the load? A late load is caught by the next fix in the first case and by luck in the second.
- Which loads need a person right now, and can a dispatcher see only those? A board that lists every active load in the same type is a call list with better fonts; the guide on how often to check on a load says what to look at instead.
- When a customer update goes out, who wrote it and who approved it? A system that texts your customer from a stale position has told them something untrue in your name.
- What is kept after delivery? For a detention claim you need the GPS arrival and departure at each stop, side by side with the driver's tapped times and the signed paperwork. A status history does not win that argument; a trip record can.
A TMS, with or without its integration, that answers all six well is doing track and trace already. The rest is the work a tool beside the TMS exists to take.
A one-week audit of your own board
Before buying anything, measure the gap on your own freight. For five working days, keep three tallies, on paper if that is what gets filled in.
First, for every load that delivered late or sat at a stop past free time, write down how the office found out: the customer called, the carrier called, a dispatcher made a check call, a driver texted, or the system raised it from a position. Note the time of the truck's problem and the time the office knew. The difference is your detection lag.
Second, at a fixed time each afternoon, count the active loads that have a position less than an hour old against the ones whose newest fact is a status someone typed. That ratio is how much of your board any tracking tool, including the one in the TMS, can actually watch. If it is low, the first job is carrier share links and driver adoption, not software.
Third, have each dispatcher tally check calls made and received for one day; the operator cost guide turns that into hours a month. Detection lag, watchable share and call hours are the purchase decision. A vendor that cannot move all three is selling you a map.
When the TMS is enough
Below roughly 25 loads a month, a status field, a phone and a dispatcher who knows every driver by name works, and a second system is overhead. A brokerage whose freight moves mostly on its own fleet, where the ELD already feeds the TMS and the dispatchers watch one screen, may also be covered. And a TMS whose tracking integration answers the six questions, with the exceptions raised on their own and customer updates approved by a person, has solved the problem where it lives, and a second tool would only duplicate it.
When a tool beside it earns its keep
A tool beside the TMS earns its keep when the audit shows the customer finding out first, when dispatchers spend the morning confirming trucks that were fine, and when detention goes unbilled because nobody can prove the dwell. Those are detection and evidence problems, and they grow with volume: at a hundred loads a month one good dispatcher covers them; at a thousand, on mixed carriers, nobody can.
The tool's job is narrow: read the truck from what the carrier already has, raise only the loads that need a person, draft what goes to the customer for approval, and leave the TMS as the record. Exception management is the name for the queue it should produce, and the guide to choosing track and trace software has the demo questions.
Where LoadSignal fits
LoadSignal is a track and trace tool that works alongside the TMS you already run. Loads come in from Rose Rocket, Turvo, McLeod, Tai TMS and Descartes Aljex, set up with each customer, and stay in step with the TMS when the carrier or the stops change; a correction a dispatcher makes in LoadSignal can be kept through later syncs. Where a TMS publishes no API, loads come in by spreadsheet, from an emailed rate confirmation, or through the public API. The Chrome Companion shows the LoadSignal load beside the TMS page, with the truck, the ETA, the alerts and the next action.
Position comes from the carrier's ELD, the driver app or a tracking link, and every load reads Active, Stale or Lost from the age of its newest fix, so the evidence always carries its age. Every active load is checked every few minutes and on every event against the rules the company sets; the stale and lost thresholds are 20 and 60 minutes by default and editable. The dashboard leads with the loads that need a person. Late load detection compares the routed ETA (a planning estimate, not a guarantee) with the appointment on every new position. A customer update is drafted for a person to approve; nothing goes to a customer without a click unless the company opts in. After delivery the trip record holds every stop with its GPS arrival and departure, and a detention claim is drafted from dwell past free time with that record as evidence.
Where LoadSignal does not fit: it is not a TMS, so rating, billing, settlements, carrier onboarding and the load board stay where they are. A brokerage whose TMS tracking already answers the six questions above does not need it. The product page lists the TMS, ELD and visibility connections and how each is set up.
Questions brokers ask
Is a track and trace tool a TMS?
No. A TMS is the record of the load: the customer, the carrier, the rate, the stops, the documents and the invoice. A track and trace tool follows the truck while the load moves, decides which loads need a person and keeps the evidence. Brokerages that run one beside the TMS keep booking, rating and billing where they are.
Do I need tracking software if my TMS already has a tracking integration?
Only if the integration leaves work on the desk. Ask what happens on its own when a position stops arriving, whether the ETA is compared with the appointment on every new position, and who approves a customer update. An integration that answers all three without a dispatcher watching is doing the job. One that shows a pin and waits for someone to look at it is not.
Will running two systems mean double entry?
It should not, and that is the first thing to test in a demo. Loads should come into the tracking tool from the TMS on their own and follow it when the carrier or the stops change. If the tool asks a dispatcher to retype the load, the two systems will drift apart within a week.
What if my TMS has no API?
Some brokerage TMSs publish no API. The loads can still get into a tracking tool by spreadsheet export, by forwarding the rate confirmation email, or from a browser extension that reads the load on the TMS page. Ask the vendor how each path behaves when a load changes after it was imported.
No TMS or visibility vendor is named on this page: it compares kinds of tracking, not products, and what any one vendor's integration does is a question for its demo. Corrections to support@getloadsignal.com.