The short answer
For a truckload broker, the choice comes down to two questions: where will the truck's position come from on each load, and who acts when that position says something is wrong? The large networks, Descartes MacroPoint, project44 and FourKites, answer the first with scale. Trucker Tools starts from the driver's phone number and sits inside DAT. Highway comes at visibility from carrier identity and requires an ELD connection. LoadSignal takes positions from several sources per load and spends most of its effort on the second question.
We sell LoadSignal, so read this with that in mind. Everything said about another vendor comes from its own public pages, its press releases or named news coverage, listed at the bottom with the date we read them. Where those sources were silent we say so, which tells you about the sources and nothing certain about the product.
How we compared
We compared five things a brokerage feels on every load: who the vendor says it builds for; how a position reaches you and what the carrier or driver has to do; what happens when a load goes wrong, whether that is an alert, an agent or a queue; whether a person can approve what your customer reads; and the price, where one is published.
We left out tools built mainly for shippers' ocean freight or high-value cargo monitoring, and capacity tools that do not track. Some vendors' website terms bar commercial use or copying of their sites, so for those we used only press releases, app store listings and news coverage. That is why FourKites and Highway are described from press material rather than their own sites.
At a glance
Each vendor column uses the sources listed at the bottom. A blank in a vendor's public material is marked as not published, not as missing from the product.
| Vendor | Built for | How positions arrive | Published price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Descartes MacroPoint | Shippers, brokers, 3PLs and carriers across truckload, LTL, parcel, air and ocean | Telematics and TMS integrations, with a mobile app as failover | Per load, from undated articles; see below |
| project44 | Enterprise shippers; LSP44, split off in July 2026, serves brokers, 3PLs and forwarders | Telematics, API or TMS, or the DriveView app; free for carriers to join | Not on the pages we read |
| FourKites | Global enterprises and large brands across road, rail, ocean and air | CarrierLink driver app and a network of 500,000+ carriers, by its own count | CarrierLink is free for drivers; no broker price found |
| Trucker Tools | Brokers tracking and sourcing capacity, owned by DAT | Driver's phone number by SMS or WhatsApp, plus ELD integrations | Not on the pages we read |
| Highway | Brokers checking carrier identity and compliance | ELD connection, required for every carrier on its system from July 5, 2026, per FreightWaves | Not in the sources we read |
| LoadSignal | US brokers, carriers and 3PLs moving truck freight, roughly 100 to 2,000 loads a month | Driver app, browser link, carrier share links, and Samsara and Motive ELD connections | No list price; quote based on load volume |
Descartes MacroPoint
MacroPoint sells to brokers as well as shippers. Its homepage counts "435,000+ carriers, logistics providers and drivers", and its pricing article says the network is built on hundreds of TMS, ELD and GPS integrations. Telematics leads, with what the cost article calls "Mobile app failover in the case where telemetry connections are interrupted". It covers parcel, LTL, air and ocean as well as full truckload, and it sells OpsForce AI agents on top of tracking.
It is also the only vendor here whose own pages discuss prices. One article puts a company sending just over 1,000 shipments a year at $0.42 to $3.75 per shipment, with implementation between $3K and $20K. The other says pricing starts at $5 per load and can fall as low as 40 cents. Neither page is dated and the figures differ, so treat them as a range to question. At 1,000 loads a month, every dollar per load is $12,000 a year. Our MacroPoint alternatives guide goes through it in detail.
project44 and LSP44
project44 calls Movement its "Decision Intelligence Platform", and its April 2026 announcement describes a network of more than 259,000 carriers and 1.5 billion shipments a year. Carriers connect through telematics, an API or TMS, or the DriveView app, and its over-the-road page says "Many carriers can self-onboard in minutes." Its carrier FAQ says joining the carrier network is free for carriers. On automation, the over-the-road page offers to handle "sharing status updates with downstream parties and identifying exceptions".
There is also a structural change. Logistics Management reported on July 14, 2026 that project44 is splitting into two businesses: one keeps the project44 name for enterprise shippers, and a new company, LSP44, serves "3PLs, freight forwarders, and brokers" with AI agents. If you are evaluating project44 as a broker, ask which of the two you would be buying from. We found no published price on the pages we read. The project44 alternatives guide goes through the choice for a broker's own loads.
Many brokers meet project44 because a shipper requires it, and that requirement stands whatever you run internally. LoadSignal can send positions and stop milestones into a shipper's project44 shipment, so the two are not either-or.
FourKites
FourKites builds for large supply chains. Its October 2026 announcement describes a network connecting "1,600+ brands, 500,000+ carriers and 3.6 million facilities across 176 countries", and it sells AI agents that, in its words, "resolve problems on a customer's behalf instead of flagging them". Brokers still meet it: the CarrierLink listing on Google Play says drivers get loads assigned by shippers and brokers, and calls the app "a free, easy to use and time saving app for truck drivers".
What we could not find is a published price for brokers, or a statement on whether a person can approve a customer message before an agent sends it. Ask to see that setting working. The FourKites alternatives guide has the rest.
Trucker Tools
Trucker Tools has been owned by DAT since December 2024, according to Transport Topics. Its load tracking starts from the driver's phone number, by SMS or WhatsApp, with ELD, temperature and trailer tracking integrations alongside. Alerts cover a truck out of range, off route or running late, and geofences. It also runs the Smart Load Board, which matters if you want capacity and tracking in one place. The pages we read show no price. More in the Trucker Tools alternatives guide.
Highway
Highway is the one vendor here that starts from carrier identity rather than tracking. Its April 2025 release calls Highway "the leader in Carrier Identity solutions" and describes Load Lock+ as "Real-time, ELD-based tracking without check calls." In July 2026, FreightWaves reported that Highway was requiring every carrier on its system to connect an ELD by July 5, in response to the Supreme Court's decision in Montgomery v. Caribe Transport, and that Highway's chief operating officer put the share already connected at about 90%.
If your main worry is who is really hauling the load, Highway is built around that question. If your main cost is the follow-up on loads that are already moving, compare what happens after the position arrives. We found no price in the sources we read.
LoadSignal
LoadSignal is built for US truckload brokers, carriers and 3PLs moving roughly 100 to 2,000 loads a month. On each load the position comes from the LoadSignal Driver app, a texted browser link, a carrier's share link from Samsara, Motive, Nomad ELD or the EVA ELD family, or a direct Samsara or Motive connection. The carrier joins no network: a carrier with a supported ELD can usually make a share link in a minute.
Eleven detectors check active loads on a five-minute schedule and on load events, and the board opens on the loads that need a person, ranked, with the evidence and its age. Your rules decide the follow-up: re-send the tracking link, text the driver, alert the people watching the load. Customer drafts wait for a person by default, and automatic milestone emails are an opt-in. An ETA is a planning estimate, not a guarantee, and once the position is lost the load reads "ETA unverified" rather than showing the old number as current.
Pass on us if you need ocean, air, rail or parcel, EDI, a large carrier network on day one, or a completed third-party audit such as SOC 2. We are a newer company with no public customer references, and our TMS connections (Rose Rocket, Turvo, McLeod, Tai TMS and Descartes Aljex) are set up with you. We do not send to MacroPoint or FourKites today.
How to choose
Start with the requirement you cannot change. If a shipper requires a platform, you will be on it. Then pull the last two weeks of loads and count three things: loads that never had a position, loads that went quiet for an hour or more, and delays you heard about from the customer first. Those numbers are your baseline, and they often point at carrier compliance, which a tracking clause on the rate confirmation helps with whichever vendor you pick.
Then run one lane or one customer on the tool for two weeks, so no driver is asked to run two trackers on one load. Score every vendor, us included, on the demo scorecard. The freight visibility page covers the terms and the position sources if you are still mapping the category. To try LoadSignal on a lane, book a demo.
Questions brokers ask
What is the best freight visibility software for a small brokerage?
There is no single answer, because the right tool depends on where your trucks' positions can come from and who has to act on them. If your shippers require a particular platform, start there. If you need one large carrier network on day one, look at the network vendors. If your problem is the follow-up, the dispatcher-hours spent watching and chasing loads, compare how each tool decides which loads need a person and what it does next.
Do I need project44 if my shipper uses it?
If the shipper requires its project44 shipments to be tracked, the requirement stands, but it does not decide what you run internally. LoadSignal can send truck positions and stop milestones into the shipper's project44 shipment, so a broker can work its loads in LoadSignal and still feed the shipper.
Which freight visibility vendors publish a price?
Of the vendors on this page, only Descartes MacroPoint publishes figures, in two undated articles that disagree with each other. The others ask you to talk to sales. LoadSignal has no list price either: each company gets a quote based on its monthly load volume.
Is freight visibility software the same as a TMS?
No. A TMS stores the load, the carrier, the rate and the billing. Visibility software follows the truck while the load moves. Most brokers run both, so ask each vendor which TMS it connects to and what it sends back.
Descartes, MacroPoint, project44, LSP44, FourKites, Trucker Tools, DAT, Highway and the other company and product names on this page belong to their owners. LoadSignal is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by any of them, and naming a company here does not mean it endorses us. If anything here has changed since we read it, write to support@getloadsignal.com and we will correct it.